Skip to main content

Table 5 Summary of Oncologic outcomes

From: Meta-analysis of subxiphoid approach versus lateral approach for thoracoscopic Thymectomy

 

SVATS

LVATS

Study

Thymoma

Tumor diameter (cm)

Masaoka staging

MG

Carcinoma

Thymoma

Tumor diameter (cm)

Masaoka staging

MG

Carcinoma

Suda Takashi

11/46

NA

Stage

I and II

11/46

0/46

27/35

NA

Stage

I and II

10/35

0/35

Hsu C-P

4/11

≤4 cm

Stage

I and II

15/15

0/15

2/10

≤4 cm

Stage

I and II

12/12

0/12

Wang, H

36/36

NA

Stage

I and II

0/36

NA

47/47

NA

Stage

I and II

0/47

NA

Yano Motoki

7/14

4.5 ± 2.7

NA

1/14

2/14

26/46

NA

NA

2/46

2/46

Lu Qiang

10/31

≤5 cm

Stage

I and II

41/41

0/41

12/24

≤5 cm

Stage

I and II

36/36

0/36

Zhang Louqian

28/28

3.2 ± 1.6

Stage

I and II

0/28

NA

70/70

3.6 ± 1.3

Stage

I and II

0/70

NA

Yong Tang

NA

NA

NA

20/20

NA

25

NA

NA

25/25

NA