Skip to main content

Table 1 Selected case reports with review of the literature

From: Primary tracheal schwannoma a review of a rare entity: current understanding of management and followup

 

Horovitz AG et al. [8]

Righini CA et al. [4]

Tang LF et al. [5]

Xiahui GE et al. [6]

Years

1950–1983

1950–2003

1950–2005

1950–2013

Cases

13

23

34

51

Adults

11 (84.6%)

19 (82.6%)

27 (80%)

40 (78.4%)

F:M

7:5 (1 not specified)

14:4 (5 not specified)

18:13 (3 not specified)

30:20 (1 not specified)

Location in the trachea

distal > proximal > middle third

distal > proximal > middle third

NR

distal > proximal > middle third

Race

White > others

NR

NR

Asian > North American > European

Symptoms

 Common

Cough, wheeze, shortness of breath and hemoptysis

Upper airway obstruction with predominance of dyspnea

Airway obstruction symptoms like nonspecific cough, wheezing, and dyspnea.

Cough, wheezing and dyspnea

 Uncommon

Fever and chest pain

Hemoptysis and chest infection

Hoarseness, hemoptysis, sudden severe dyspnea

Hemoptysis, hoarseness and chest pain

Signs

NR

NR

Pneumomediastinum, subcutaneous emphysema, and fever

Wheeze or Stridor 15 (29%)

Investigation

Fluoroscopy, Xeroradiographs and tomograms

CT of the chest

Tracheobronchoscopy

CT of the chest

MRI (1 case)

Tracheobronchoscopy

PFT

CT of the chest

MRI

Tracheobronchoscopy

PFT

CT of the chest

Tracheobronchoscopy

Delay of the diagnosis

10–15 months

10–15 months

NR

17 months

Tumor size

NR

NR

NR

1–4 cm

Treatment

 Endoscopic resection

(Laser, electronic snaring, APC, cryotherapy, endoscopic excision)

5 (38%)

NR

NR

19 (37%)

 Surgical resection

8 (62%)

NR

NR

33 (71%)

(29 primary treatment and 4 for relapse after endoscopic resection)

Recurrence

 Endoscopic resection

1 (20%)

1 (4%)

3(8.6%)

4 (21%)

 Surgery

0 (0%)

0 (0.0%)

0 (0.0%)

0 (0%)

Malignant histology

NR

NR

2 (5.7%

2 (3.9%)

Complication

2

NR

3 (8.6%)

3 (6%)

 

â–ª Renal Failure

â–ª Post-operative infection

 

â–ª Renal Failure

â–ª Post-operative infection

â–ª Hypoxic brain damage

â–ª Renal Failure

â–ª Post-operative infection

â–ª Hypoxic brain damage

  1. NR not recorded, CT computer tomography, MRI Magnetic Resonance Image, PFT Pulmonary Function Test, cm centimeter