Authors | Yrs | Design | Study Cohort | “Delayed” cohort | Comparison cohort “control” | Delayed cohort inclusion criteria | Control inclusion criteria. | Definition Malperfusion | Preoperative biochemistry (delayed) | Delayed cohort strategy | Control cohort strategy | Hybrid theatre? | Time to definitive (aortic) repair |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Leshnower et al. [18] | 2003 2017 | Retrospective | ATAAD with MPS | ATAAD and MM | Central repair first in setting of MM | Carefully selected patients. CI to haemodynamic instability. | Haemodynamic instability /rupture | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | Reported as individual patient data | 13 TEVAR 3 ax-bifemoral bypass | 10 hemiarch 2 root replacements | Yes | 24 H after reperfusion |
Yamashiro et al. [19] | 2000 2014 | Retrospective | ATAAD and visceral malperfusion | ATAAD and MM | Central repair first in setting of MM | Carefully selected patients. CI to haemodynamic instability, | Haemodynamic instability /rupture | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | BE: −2.8 ± 1.2 Lactate 3.3 ± 1.2 a | Emergency Laparotomy/bypass before central repair relook laparotomy post central repair | Not Specified | No | Not reported |
Patel H et al. [20] | 1997 2007 | Retrospective | Patients with ATAAD malperfusion (all) | ATAAD and MM (subgroup) | No - Not specified for MM p | Carefully selected patients. CI to haemodynamic instability, | N/A | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | Not reported | Angiography with percutaneous fenestration and aortic true lumen stenting with or without branch vessel stenting | N/A | No | median 4 days after reperfusion |
Uchida et al. [21] | 2006 2016 | Retrospective | Patients with ATAAD and CT or clinical evidence of malperfusion (all types) | ATAAD and MM | Central repair first in setting of MM | Unclear – potentially change in protocol over later to contemporary time periods | Unclear – potentially change in protocol over later to contemporary time periods | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | Not reported | Laparotomy and atom tube into SMA | Not Specified | No | Immediately after reperfusion |
Deeb et al. [7] | 1992 1996 | Retrospective | Patients with ATAAD and CT or clinical evidence of malperfusion (all types) | ATAAD and MM | Central repair first in setting of MM | Unclear – potentially change in protocol over later to contemporary time periods | Unclear – potentially change in protocol over later to contemporary time periods | visceral: pain associated with physical findings compatible with an acute abdomen and associated abnormal laboratory findings. | Not reported | Fenestration of the aortic dissection flap accompanied by the stenting of compromised branch vessel | Root = 6, Hemiarch = 2, Ascending aorta = 1, total arch = 2 | No | Median (days) 23 (IQR 2–57) after reperfusion |
Yang et al. [22] | 1996 2017 | Retrospective | ATAAD with mesenteric malperfusion | ATAAD with MM | No (single arm study) | Carefully selected patients. CI to haemodynamic instability, | N/A | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | 7 ± 8.5 (max serum lactate mean) | IR, endovascular fenestration ± SMA stenting or suction thrombectomy if static obstruction 10 patients required further laparotomy and bowel resection. | Root replacement 14, Root repair 28, Arch 27, FET 2. | No | Median (days) 6 (IQR 2–19) |
Tsagakis et al. [23] | 2004 2011 | Retrospective | ATAAD and malperfusion (All) | ATAAD with MPS | Yes – Central repair first in the setting of MM (subgroup) | Carefully selected patients. CI to haemodynamic instability, | Rupture/CPR and other reasons: Age less than 50 years (6/34), cardiogenic shock (17/34) Tamponade (5/34) previous coronary angiograms (2/34) unavailability of the Hybrid OR (4/34) | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | Not reported | All endovascular: four fenestrations, six splitting of the true limen, | Not Specified | Yes | Immediately after |
Sugiyama et al. [24] | 2017–2019 | Retrospective | ATAAD with mesenteric malperfusion | ATAAD with MPS | Central repair first in setting of MM | Carefully selected patients. CI to haemodynamic instability, | Haemodynamic instability /rupture | CT Cross sectional evidence of ischemia along with symptoms | Not reported | Not reported | Hemiarch = 2, total arch = 2 | Yes | Not reported |